Litigation Paralegal Personal Injury

Pay: $65,000.00 - $85,000.00 per year

Why This Is a Great Opportunity

• Take ownership of meaningful litigation cases from intake through resolution or trial.
• Work directly with experienced attorneys who value your ideas, judgment, and initiative.
• Make a real difference for individuals and families navigating challenging legal situations.
• Join a collaborative, team-oriented environment where your contributions are recognized.
• Enjoy the opportunity to take on responsibility, sharpen your litigation skills, and grow professionally.

Location

Shelbyville, IN | On-site

Join our team in Shelbyville, Indiana, where you'll enjoy a collaborative office environment, direct attorney interaction, and the opportunity to play an important role in every case. This is a full-time, on-site position.

Note

Candidates must have 3+ years of civil litigation paralegal experience and be able to work on-site in Shelbyville, IN. Personal injury litigation experience is highly preferred, but experienced civil litigation paralegals from other practice areas are encouraged to apply.

About Us

Confidential Employer

We are a dedicated, client-focused law firm committed to delivering strong legal representation and meaningful results. Our team handles complex civil litigation and personal injury matters with care, professionalism, and attention to detail. We believe great legal work comes from collaboration, thoughtful problem-solving, and people who take pride in making things happen.

We're looking for a proactive Litigation Paralegal who wants to be more than just a support person. We want someone who enjoys thinking critically, taking ownership, and helping move cases forward.

Job Description

• Manage civil litigation and personal injury cases from initial client meetings through settlement or trial.
• Work closely with attorneys to develop cases, organize evidence, and support litigation strategy.
• Gather, review, and analyze medical records, legal documents, and other case materials.
• Draft and prepare pleadings, discovery requests and responses, and settlement-related documents.
• Track litigation deadlines, maintain organized case files, and proactively advance matters.
• Coordinate depositions, mediations, court filings, and trial preparation.
• Communicate professionally with clients, attorneys, medical providers, and insurance representatives.
• Identify potential issues, anticipate next steps, and help keep every case moving efficiently.

Qualifications

• 3+ years of civil litigation paralegal experience required.
• Experience managing litigation files and supporting attorneys through multiple stages of a case.
• Strong experience with legal document preparation, records review, discovery, and deadline management.
• Excellent organization, communication, and analytical skills.
• Ability to work independently, prioritize deadlines, and collaborate with attorneys.
• Plaintiff-side personal injury litigation experience preferred.
• A proactive, detail-oriented mindset and genuine commitment to client service.

Why You Will Love Working Here

We believe great paralegals deserve the opportunity to make an impact. Here, you'll work closely with attorneys who appreciate initiative, thoughtful analysis, and collaboration. You'll have meaningful responsibility, opportunities to strengthen your litigation expertise, and the satisfaction of helping clients through important moments in their lives.

JPC - 2665

Benefits:

• Health insurance
• Life insurance
• Vision insurance

Requirements: Must-have: 3+ yrs of Civil Litigation Paralegal

• Required Years as Associate: 3

Submission Email:Mike - [email protected]

Quick Recruiter Reference

Civil litigation firm focused on personal injury, wrongful death, and complex injury claims. Seeking a paralegal with 3+ years of civil litigation experience to manage cases from intake through trial, including pleadings, discovery, records analysis, and deadlines. Shelbyville, IN, on-site; strong independent case management skills required.

Recruiters Submission: To submit, cancel - Litigation Paralegal – Personal Injury - Stephenson Rife, LLP - JPC- 2665 - source

New Job Order Alert

• Client job title: Litigation Paralegal – Personal Injury
• Location: Shelbyville, IN
• On-site, hybrid, remote: On-site
• Experience: 3+
• Good fit job titles/keywords for candidates: Civil Litigation Paralegal, Personal Injury Paralegal, Senior Litigation Paralegal, Trial Paralegal, Plaintiff PI Paralegal

• of hires needed: 1